GBR Sex Challenge

[Wilkes]

Apologise for the confusion, let me try and clarify. When I first posted the pictures of my fish 1 and 2 the replies i got were saying there was a female and male. The picture I posted the second time round was of the "female" but now people believe its a feminine male. See my dilemma? This is the dominant one so before when I explained the dominant one was female, that was because I was working of the suggestions from the first post. It would make more sense if it did turn out to be a male and the other GBR was a juvenile male. This is what I believe I have been given hence the unrest in the tank.

 

[bs6749]

Then you misunderstood the replies given. Go back to the thread here: http://www.aquariumadvice.com/forums/f15/question-about-german-blue-rams-193715-4.html and look at post #33. The top two pictures that you called "fish #1" with the black on the anterior edge of the pelvic fins are of your female. The bottom two pictures are of the fish that you called "fish #2" with the extended dorsal rays are of your male, which I said was a feminine looking male.

You then posted this tread with two pictures of "fish #2", clearly seen from the extended dorsal rays and matching the fishes unique color pattern to that seen in your other thread. This fish is male. I think the confusion here is on your part (no offense meant) as to what we were calling male and what we were calling female.