jeffaquarius
Aquarium Advice Addict
I would say that we are having a good discussion on the topic since everyone is learning including myself as we go along. With the throttle valve the pump discharge pressure will be higher than the valve outlet (upper side) and not equal. Water is liquid and compressible just like oil used in hydraulics. Have you wondered why there is pressure gauge on the pumps? Don't forget that water has weight and the higher you are lifting it, the higher the pressure you need at the bottom to raise it up to the top. The pressure at the bottom is higher than at the top (they are not equal). If your read the link below and really understand it, hopefully it will clarify all the issues we are dealing with. Take note of the MINIMUM HEAD. It stops to a point where the pump will be overloaded once it is below that curve, Try to run your return pump with the discharge at the water level of your sump or even lower and you will see how the heat will rise noticeably.
What is head?
With regards to the HEAT of the pump motor, there is always heat being radiated regardless of how much work is being done. However, we know that the more power being consumed the more heat loss is present. At 90% efficient you already have 10% heating up the pump. One example when a throttle valve is necessary is when the pump has been installed in a system that is more than it can handle. Meaning it is undersized or overloaded. So what do you do? Your option is either to replace the discharge pipe to a smaller size to reduce the flow or you can install a throttle valve. I would choose the later since it is variable while the former is not.
What is head?
With regards to the HEAT of the pump motor, there is always heat being radiated regardless of how much work is being done. However, we know that the more power being consumed the more heat loss is present. At 90% efficient you already have 10% heating up the pump. One example when a throttle valve is necessary is when the pump has been installed in a system that is more than it can handle. Meaning it is undersized or overloaded. So what do you do? Your option is either to replace the discharge pipe to a smaller size to reduce the flow or you can install a throttle valve. I would choose the later since it is variable while the former is not.