Not to be a smarty pants here but it seems that all the people above did help you. I know it isn't what you were hoping to hear but the info they gave you was good info. They just don't want to see you have a bunch of heart ache if it didn't work out. It is up to you but, if I were you, I would listen to what they say. Stick with reef safe fish if you want a reef. If you want non-reef safe fish, go fowlr. If you try to do both, you are tanking a risk. None of us can change the facts but just try to live with them. Hope that helps.