Thank Aqua_Chem. I'll try not to bother you after this: I have the citric acid/bicarbonate in pop bottles set up. It's okay, but not great. I get very frustrated trying to regulate the bubbles. Speeds up, slows down to nothing; it has a very inconsistent dial. I get by with it, but also I've not been able to grow anything beyond the really basic plants (and I usually tear them all out due to algae every few months.)
When you say I'm underdosing, do you mean I'm under utilizing Flourish? (I'm following the directions)... how could I improve that if I stick with my finicky C02 system for now.
I'm not going to jump into a pressurized CO2 but I'm sorely tempted when I get another couple paychecks. I'm thinking of this sort of system - easy to set up for equipment-phobic people.
Complete CO2 Systems | CO2 Regulator - PH Controller - Cylinder
Does anyone of those systems appeal?
Thanks for your expertise.
Having shifted to pressurised co2 and a ph controller I'd never go back. Make sure you have a needle valve though for fine-tuning co2 delivery as I still find bps a useful check. Just in case you go down that road. The needle valve is good as a ph controller will turn co2 on/off at certain ph levels however the needle valve makes it easier to control co2 flow rate.
I'm not sure if it's just my bottle but I do find I need to adjust flow rate slightly as the bottle empties.
However even with a ph controller it's not quite set and forget (but close!). A ph controller does need calibrating every so often and I have a digital ph pen to check it. If the ph controller failed I wouldn't need to rush out and replace it (although would) so regard it as a 'useful to have'. A drop checker and bps counter will do most of it especially as you are used to co2 dosing anyway. So you could save funds there. Otherwise as suits.
Sort out co2 and next up the plants will run out of one of the ferts (grr). Potassium mainly for me. No worries, as above a ferts package will last for ages and once you get the dosing schedule sorted pretty easy. I tend to dose each fert separately now and check tank with test kits for water chemistry but I'm apparently in the 1% that likes doing that ?
Then it's working through plants that will out-compete the algae. I always find the store plant doesn't do well until new leaves come up and it adjusts to the tank.
Substrate, substrate ferts and water flow are also I think important. I've had great growth rates with just little pots of soil capped with gravel under low light and no CO2. I think substrate is worth thinking about along with ferts, co2 and lights.
I think it just takes time to get sorted so now I do think if something is causing trouble, ditch it and replace as a planted tank is always a balancing act and you don't want something holding you back.
In lighter moments I confess I think I should of just got goldfish.