Will different species of Cory school together?

The friendliest place on the web for anyone with an interest in aquariums or fish keeping!
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.

johnt2k14

Aquarium Advice Regular
Joined
Nov 3, 2014
Messages
55
Was at liveaquaria's website browsing the Corys. Noticed they have suggested minimum numbers to be kept in a tank. For example, 4 peppered cory is the minimum. When it comes to Corys, does that mean 4 of the same species or could I mix 2 peppered with 2 panda without undo harm to the fish?

-John
 
There is a ton of augments about this.
IME I will always do a school of exact same species if at all possible. I think you really see better behaviors. And Planet Catfish suggests 6 of each species as a min. FYI.

You won't "harm" them, but they may be shy or not thrive. Also check temps to see if they are compatible. Pandas like cooler water and die young in overly warm tanks.

http://youtu.be/tPOvOije4vQ


Smoke signals from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Your Corydoras

Hello John...

Corys aren't schooling fish, they're shoaling fish. It's a difference between a tight group making the same move and a very loose group foraging in different directions. If you're looking for a schooling fish, watch any species of Tetra, those are schooling fish.

Corys of different species may or may not stay in a group. Mine don't.

B
 
I agree with Coursair, except I didn't know about Pandas liking cooler water, wish I'd known about that... When I kept corys, the problem was I ended up with different species at different times because the fish stores didn't always have the kind( s) I already had. For a long time I didn't realize they needed to be all the same species, and was trying to keep the numbers up to at least 6.


Sent from my iPad using Aquarium Advice
 
Hello John...



Corys aren't schooling fish, they're shoaling fish. It's a difference between a tight group making the same move and a very loose group foraging in different directions. If you're looking for a schooling fish, watch any species of Tetra, those are schooling fish.



Corys of different species may or may not stay in a group. Mine don't.



B

A group of fish is called a School in common usage.

Per Wiki
"Corydoras are generally found in smaller-sized streams, along the margins of larger rivers, in marshes and ponds.[2] They are native to slow-moving and almost still (but seldom stagnant) streams and small rivers of South America where the water is shallow and very clear.[citation needed] Most species are bottom-dwellers, foraging in sand, gravel, or detritus.[2] The banks and sides of the streams are covered with a dense growth of plants, and this is where the corys are found. They inhabit a wide variety of water types but tend toward soft, neutral to slightly acidic or slightly alkaline pH and 5-10 degrees of hardness. They can tolerate only a small amount of salt (some species tolerate none at all) and do not inhabit environments with tidal influences.[citation needed]

They are often seen in shoals.[2] Most species prefer being in groups and many species are found in SCHOOLS or aggregations of hundreds or even thousands of individuals, usually of a single species, but occasionally with other species mixed in.[citation needed] Unlike most catfishes which are nocturnal, Corydoras species are active during the daytime.[2]"

It is easier to call a group a school as a general term.


While schooling and shoaling mean different things within biology, they are often treated as synonyms by non-specialists, with speakers of British English tending to use "shoaling" to describe any grouping of fish, while speakers of American English tend to use "schooling" just as loosely.[1]


So, Yes I know the terminology. I also know that in the US we call a group of fish a school, even Corydoras.

If you choose to continue debating the American English language you can PM me.

Regards



Smoke signals from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Thank you all for the replies.

So the bottom line is the suggested tank number is for those of the same species. I can deal with that. (y)

-John
 
My Cory's hang out together all day.. Other Peppered is just out of frame.
 

Attachments

  • 1418323549838.jpg
    1418323549838.jpg
    131.4 KB · Views: 611
I had 6 different types in one tank and they all hung out together all the time.

Sent from my SM-G900P using Aquarium Advice mobile app
 
I agree with BBradbury, they do stay together but forage in different directions, fish like pristells and neon's swim together the same way..........
 
Well Paps tank listed is a 50 column, which doesn't provide the space one normally assumes comes with a 50 gallon.
 
I'm not sure what you mean aqua, space would not stop ground dwellers doing what they do best, foraging in different directions........
 
I'm not sure what you mean aqua, space would not stop ground dwellers doing what they do best, foraging in different directions........


A column has a different footprint than a standard tank. A standard 50 is 36"x18" whereas a column will depend on overall height. I believe the standard 50 column is around 22-24" diameter.


Sent from my iPhone using Aquarium Advice
 
I'm not sure what you mean aqua, space would not stop ground dwellers doing what they do best, foraging in different directions........


With respect to the topic at hand, space, or a lack thereof, has a profound impact on behavior. For example, I could keep 10 different Corys in a 10 gallon tank and say "look they're all hanging out together". Well yeah...where else are they going to hang out but with each other in a tank of that size/dimensions? I'm taking that to an extreme just to illustrate the point. You can get them to behave certain ways by keeping them certain ways.

I used to think all my different rainbows schooled together, because they did. In a 4 foot tank. But once I moved them to a 6 foot tank the different species no longer schooled together. I would have had to see it to believe it, but sure enough they were separate schools.
 
Back
Top Bottom