ADF question.

The friendliest place on the web for anyone with an interest in aquariums or fish keeping!
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.

absolutangel04

Daphnia are People Too.
Joined
Jun 30, 2011
Messages
8,885
Location
Lincoln, NE
I have never had an ADF before and I have been trying to research them but I keep finding conflicting advice about their space requirements and needs. While reading other threads on here I picked up that most members say 5 gallons is the minimum requirement for 1 frog. I have a 10 gallon with a betta, ember tetras, and a nerite snail. Could a single ADF live in there happily, or is that a bad idea?
 
Not sure with the other fish, particularly the betta and snail. If I were you I'd post this question in the Amphibian care area. Siva is a member here with LOTS of ADF experience and some great advice, she'll probably see it there (or you could just send her a PM).
 
Not sure with the other fish, particularly the betta and snail. If I were you I'd post this question in the Amphibian care area. Siva is a member here with LOTS of ADF experience and some great advice, she'll probably see it there (or you could just send her a PM).
Thanks. I guess I never scrolled down far enough past the freshwater section to see the amphibian section!
 
Now that my thread is where it should be, does anybody else with experience with ADF have an idea if I could comfortably house a couple in my 10 gallon?
 
I don't see why u couldn't have two. I have heard that they can be difficult to feed. What substrate do u have? If u have gravel u may want to put a plate or
Something with a flat surface to keep their food from falling into any kind of cracks or crevices where they cannot get to it. Also make sure it's easy for them To swim to the top :)
 
They are social creatures, so you would definitely want more than one. You could add 3 frogs and not be overstocked, however I don't recommend mixing ADF's and fish. A couple issues can come up: First being the frogs are nearly blind and can have a hard time competing for food with the fish. And second there is the potential for frog on fish or fish on frog violence. Many a frog has ripped up a betta and vice versa. This is not to say some aren't kept together successfully long term, but it's risky. It's also possible adult frogs may hunt those embers. They may be too small to mix with the frogs IMO.

Whether keeping them alone or in a community, it's best to feed them in the same spot every day, so they know where to find their food when they smell it. You can use their fav hidey hole or cave, or even use a feeding dish. In a community setting I would place the food somewhere discrete where hopefully they can get to it before the betta. I would hand feed them when feeding frozen foods since any betta will surely sniff out worms or shrimp before the frogs get to them. Only feed the frogs thawed frozen foods and frog and tadpole bites(HBH brand is great). I alternate every other day between the two. They have sensitive digestive systems so avoid any other types of pellets and freeze dried foods. Much like bettas, they do best at 80 degrees, and with care taken to assure there are no sharp eges or pokeys on plants and decor that could damage their sensitive skin. They loove live plants...especially ones that allow them to rest at the suface, such as pennywort. They often dash up for air and dive back down quickly, slamming into things in the tank. Be sure everything is firmly planted in the substrate and cannot be knocked over by a frog so they can't become pinned and drown. And, of course, they need a tank with a good lid. :)
 
They are social creatures, so you would definitely want more than one. You could add 3 frogs and not be overstocked, however I don't recommend mixing ADF's and fish. A couple issues can come up: First being the frogs are nearly blind and can have a hard time competing for food with the fish. And second there is the potential for frog on fish or fish on frog violence. Many a frog has ripped up a betta and vice versa. This is not to say some aren't kept together successfully long term, but it's risky. It's also possible adult frogs may hunt those embers. They may be too small to mix with the frogs IMO.

Whether keeping them alone or in a community, it's best to feed them in the same spot every day, so they know where to find their food when they smell it. You can use their fav hidey hole or cave, or even use a feeding dish. In a community setting I would place the food somewhere discrete where hopefully they can get to it before the betta. I would hand feed them when feeding frozen foods since any betta will surely sniff out worms or shrimp before the frogs get to them. Only feed the frogs thawed frozen foods and frog and tadpole bites(HBH brand is great). I alternate every other day between the two. They have sensitive digestive systems so avoid any other types of pellets and freeze dried foods. Much like bettas, they do best at 80 degrees, and with care taken to assure there are no sharp eges or pokeys on plants and decor that could damage their sensitive skin. They loove live plants...especially ones that allow them to rest at the suface, such as pennywort. They often dash up for air and dive back down quickly, slamming into things in the tank. Be sure everything is firmly planted in the substrate and cannot be knocked over by a frog so they can't become pinned and drown. And, of course, they need a tank with a good lid. :)

That is so crazy! I once had one with a betta and they were pretty much best friends. I had no idea they had the potential to kill one another. sad.
 
They are social creatures, so you would definitely want more than one. You could add 3 frogs and not be overstocked, however I don't recommend mixing ADF's and fish. A couple issues can come up: First being the frogs are nearly blind and can have a hard time competing for food with the fish. And second there is the potential for frog on fish or fish on frog violence. Many a frog has ripped up a betta and vice versa. This is not to say some aren't kept together successfully long term, but it's risky. It's also possible adult frogs may hunt those embers. They may be too small to mix with the frogs IMO.

Whether keeping them alone or in a community, it's best to feed them in the same spot every day, so they know where to find their food when they smell it. You can use their fav hidey hole or cave, or even use a feeding dish. In a community setting I would place the food somewhere discrete where hopefully they can get to it before the betta. I would hand feed them when feeding frozen foods since any betta will surely sniff out worms or shrimp before the frogs get to them. Only feed the frogs thawed frozen foods and frog and tadpole bites(HBH brand is great). I alternate every other day between the two. They have sensitive digestive systems so avoid any other types of pellets and freeze dried foods. Much like bettas, they do best at 80 degrees, and with care taken to assure there are no sharp eges or pokeys on plants and decor that could damage their sensitive skin. They loove live plants...especially ones that allow them to rest at the suface, such as pennywort. They often dash up for air and dive back down quickly, slamming into things in the tank. Be sure everything is firmly planted in the substrate and cannot be knocked over by a frog so they can't become pinned and drown. And, of course, they need a tank with a good lid. :)
Thank you very much for sharing your knowledge! That is a lot of helpful information for me to consider.
 
Back
Top Bottom