Go Back   Aquarium Advice - Aquarium Forum Community > Saltwater and Reef > Saltwater & Reef - Getting Started
Click Here to Login

Join Aquarium Advice Today
Closed Thread
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
Please support our sponsors and let them know you heard about them on AquariumAdvice.com
 
Old 12-01-2008, 09:09 PM   #31
Aquarium Advice Freak
 
Join Date: Jun 2008
Posts: 429
oh maybe it was his fathers book i read
__________________

__________________
My Tanks
brutus is offline  
Old 12-01-2008, 09:38 PM   #32
Aquarium Advice Addict
 
Zagz's Avatar



POTM Champion
 
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Saskatchewan, Canada
Posts: 17,108
Send a message via MSN to Zagz
You have provided one source for your theory. I haven't read the book so I can't comment on the book.

I can however state that my uncle kept fish for many years and has some considerably outdated ideas that he stands behind today. It is possible that the author of the book has the same frame of mind.

Whenever I have done any type of research into fish vs. fishless cycling, I have always found references to ammonia and nitrite being toxic to fish of both FW and SW aquaria.

You have stated your opinion and are most certainly entitled to it. You will find however that the majority of members here will disagree and will choose fishless cycling. Their opinions are to be respected as well as yours. I personally disagree with fish cycling, but can clearly see I would not be able to talk you out of your opinion. I can agree to disagree.
__________________

__________________
AA Community Rules | AA TOS

-----------
Site Administrator
Zagz is offline  
Old 12-01-2008, 09:38 PM   #33
Aquarium Advice FINatic
 
Join Date: Nov 2008
Posts: 564
Quote:
Originally Posted by 919 View Post
First printing 1998...
that was the first printing of the second edition i believe... ive read it... it contradicts every other book ive been reading....


but dont take it from me... im just a

-Brad
__________________
Brad.Sedore is offline  
Old 12-02-2008, 12:56 AM   #34
Aquarium Advice Addict
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: not here anymore
Posts: 5,338
Quote:
Originally Posted by 919 View Post
Everyone needs to step back and relax a little...

1. Damsels are hardy fish, and recommended as a cycle fish in "The Conscientious Marine Aquarist" by Fenner. Widely viewed as the definitive reference on salt water aquariums.

2. I am posting my parameters to show, that my tanks is cycling and my fish are fine.

3. Every time I have cycled, utilizing other means; I have always experienced a mini cycle no matter how slowly I add additional fish.

4. I have yet to see any definitive quantifiable evidence that cycling with fish is not any worse than without fish. I understand the value of rules of thumb, but following them blindly is a horrible idea.
919... thanks for finally posting your reasons. I wasn't trying to bait you, but I just wanted to know your reasons - even if I don't agree with them. As long as the thread stays on topic and doesn't get nasty, it doesn't seem like it should be closed or locked, but that's just my opinion. If folks don't want to read it, then well... don't read it!

You say that there is no quantifiable evidence that cycling with fish is any worse (for the tank) than cycling without. Strictly from an ammonia standpoint, I believe you're correct. Ammonia is ammonia, whether it's from fish poop/respiration/feeding or something rotting away. But the flip side of that argument (which is also true) is that there is no quantifiable evidence to say that cycling with fish is any BETTER - which you are claiming. Both methods supply the needed ammonia.

Where I think many folks run into problems with fishless cycling is that they don't get enough ammonia in there to start with, and don't build up enough bacteria to really handle the first fish. Or they often add too many to start with. Not sure if any of these possibilities could explain your experiences, but having cycled my main tank and a quarantine tank fishless, I can vouch that it will cycle a tank and in my case have no measurable cycle as livestock are added.

Regarding the comment that you're posting your parameters that show you're cycling, and the fish "are fine"... well... I guess the fact that they're alive is the definition of "fine." I think that's were most folks will disagree with you.

Finally... before trotting out Mr. Fenner's book as your strongest support, you should read some of his more recent writings here:

EstBioFiltMar

I'll quote part of Mr. Fenner's article here:

About Damsels & Torturing Other Wildlife :In the Dark Ages, back in the 1950’s, when such pet-fish luminaries as Robert Straughan were discovering and disseminating how to set-up working marine systems, people fell into the habit of using "tougher" livestock like Damselfishes (family Pomacentridae), Anemones… even brackish Turtle species to provide starter and ongoing ammonia to establish nutrient cycling. Turns out, these organisms aren’t necessary, nor advised. There is plenty of ammonia available from live rock, live sand organisms, old/used media, and even starter cultures.

As you said, following blindly is a horrible idea.
__________________
Kurt_Nelson is offline  
Old 12-02-2008, 10:06 PM   #35
919
Aquarium Advice Activist
 
Join Date: Jul 2006
Posts: 108
Time Date Ammonia Nitrate Nitrite Alkalinity pH Temp Salinity Notes 8:00 12/2/2008 3 20 0 300 7.8 79 1.0215 cleaned brown film off substrate
__________________
919 is offline  
Old 12-03-2008, 10:56 PM   #36
919
Aquarium Advice Activist
 
Join Date: Jul 2006
Posts: 108
Time Date Ammonia Nitrate Nitrite Alkalinity pH Temp Salinity Notes 8:55 12/3/2008 3 20 0 300 7.8 79 1.0215 6 healthy looking fish
__________________
919 is offline  
Old 12-06-2008, 01:17 AM   #37
919
Aquarium Advice Activist
 
Join Date: Jul 2006
Posts: 108
Time Date Ammonia Nitrate Nitrite Alkalinity pH Temp Salinity Notes 9:24 12/5/2008 3 20 0.5 300 7.8 79 1.0215
__________________
919 is offline  
Old 12-06-2008, 10:17 PM   #38
919
Aquarium Advice Activist
 
Join Date: Jul 2006
Posts: 108
Time Date Ammonia Nitrate Nitrite Alkalinity pH Temp Salinity 8:15 12/6/2008 3 20 1 300 7.8 79 1.022
__________________
919 is offline  
Old 12-13-2008, 06:23 PM   #39
919
Aquarium Advice Activist
 
Join Date: Jul 2006
Posts: 108
Time Date Ammonia Nitrate Nitrite Alkalinity pH Temp Salinity Notes 7:30 12/11/2008 2.0 20 0.5 300 7.8 79 1.022 6 healthy fish
__________________
919 is offline  
Old 12-13-2008, 06:25 PM   #40
919
Aquarium Advice Activist
 
Join Date: Jul 2006
Posts: 108
Time Date Ammonia Nitrate Nitrite Alkalinity pH Temp Salinity Notes 4:22 12/13/2008 2 20 0 300 7.8 79 1.022 6 healthy fish
__________________

__________________
919 is offline  
Closed Thread

Tags
5 gallon, 55 gallon, cycle, tan

Please support our sponsors and let them know you heard about them on AquariumAdvice.com

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are Off


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
20 gallon cycle w/ fish Cantra Saltwater & Reef - Getting Started 8 12-08-2008 04:38 PM
How to cycle New 180 gallon tank efeeley Freshwater & Brackish - Getting Started 8 06-21-2006 09:01 PM
New Tank Questions - 55 Gallon Cycle In 6 Days?!? noteworthy Saltwater & Reef - Getting Started 12 08-05-2005 01:49 AM
How long will the tank cycle per gallon? mr86mister Freshwater & Brackish - Getting Started 23 06-10-2005 08:47 AM
To cycle or not to cycle.... (2-gallon tank) fearlessfisch Freshwater & Brackish - Getting Started 3 10-17-2004 01:34 PM







» Photo Contest Winners








Copyright 2002- Social Knowledge, LLC All Rights Reserved.

All times are GMT -4. The time now is 01:55 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8 Beta 1
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.