Fishless cycle with carbon in the OTB or not?

[Deckape]

Hi, I started my 55 gallon up last night with advice from the site. All are awesome. But it wasn't readily apparent to me if the carbon filter inserts should be there or not. My ammonia level is at 4 ppm and Ph is about 8.2. I did a PWC this morning because I got an amost 8ppm. Just wondering and thanks for the reply from the member when I asked this in someone else's thread. He or she said no but just wondering if there are any other schools of thought. Appreciate any answers. Love this site OBTW.

 

[OhNeil1969]

I have to admit I never really gave the idea much thought. My 29 gallon tank cycled with carbon in it's filter. I really don't see how it can hurt. The only thing I'd be concerned about is that the carbon will be ineffective by the time you add your fish.

 

[BigJim]

Save the carbon. I only use the carbon if I'm trying to remove tannins or medication from the water.

 

[hdultra]

Save the carbon. I only use the carbon if I'm trying to remove tannins or medication from the water.

I second what big Jim Said.

 

[Deckape]

That's what I was thinking. Thanks everyone. I will lean on y'all if you don't mind from time to time. Thanks again

 

[hdultra]

That's what I was thinking. Thanks everyone. I will lean on y'all if you don't mind from time to time. Thanks again

That's why were here.