Would I be overstocked?

The friendliest place on the web for anyone with an interest in aquariums or fish keeping!
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.

Reaper216

Aquarium Advice Activist
Joined
Sep 16, 2013
Messages
184
Location
Vero Beach, Florida
Let me start by saying that I understand that the AqAdvisor Calculator says it is at 119%. I have read online that they might be very conservative and rate a little high. That being said I have not added this many fish and dont plan on doing so for a few months. Never if feedback says otherwise!

Also, in the next few months I'm planning on adding a sump tank. A 30G possibly,

This is what I have in my tank currently

http://aqadvisor.com/AquStockImage....200909300248:,5:200911161252:,2:200909300134:

This is what I want, or something like it. I wanted 2 more, different schools of fish. I also wanted to DG as a centerpiece. My original thought was an angel, but I hear they might try to eat the neons.

http://aqadvisor.com/AquStockImage....0909300061:,10:200909300144:,10:200911191421:

I'm thinking about removing the zebras. I'm going to see if my lfs will either buy/give credit for them. I originally got them in my 40 fish buying spree (new to the hobby and unaware) because they were apart of the dollar sale.

Removing the zebras gives me this

http://aqadvisor.com/AquStockImage....0909300061:,10:200909300144:,10:200911191421:

I have now come to realize there is more to fish care then what first appears, and that you just might have to spend more than $1 to get the fish that you will enjoy.

Thoughts?
 
Let me start by saying that I understand that the AqAdvisor Calculator says it is at 119%. I have read online that they might be very conservative and rate a little high. That being said I have not added this many fish and dont plan on doing so for a few months. Never if feedback says otherwise!

Also, in the next few months I'm planning on adding a sump tank. A 30G possibly,

This is what I have in my tank currently

http://aqadvisor.com/AquStockImage.php?N=&L=36&D=15&H=18&J=&UV=gUS&UL=inch&F=9:201001021209:,4:200909300248:,5:200911161252:,2:200909300134:

This is what I want, or something like it. I wanted 2 more, different schools of fish. I also wanted to DG as a centerpiece. My original thought was an angel, but I hear they might try to eat the neons.

http://aqadvisor.com/AquStockImage.php?N=&L=36&D=15&H=18&J=&UV=gUS&UL=inch&F=9:201001021209:,4:200909300248:,5:200911161252:,2:200909300134:,1:200909300061:,10:200909300144:,10:200911191421:

I'm thinking about removing the zebras. I'm going to see if my lfs will either buy/give credit for them. I originally got them in my 40 fish buying spree (new to the hobby and unaware) because they were apart of the dollar sale.

Removing the zebras gives me this

http://aqadvisor.com/AquStockImage.php?N=&L=48&D=14&H=25&J=&UV=gUS&UL=inch&F=9:201001021209:,5:200911161252:,2:200909300134:,1:200909300061:,10:200909300144:,10:200911191421:

I have now come to realize there is more to fish care then what first appears, and that you just might have to spend more than $1 to get the fish that you will enjoy.

Thoughts?

It's the mollys that stock your tank. Without them you could add so much morez
 
Well, I absolutely love my Mollys, just wanted a school or 2 to fill the "gap" so to speak. If I cant add anything too them Ill just have to forget adding anything.

A little upsetting but I cant give them up. 3 of them lived through me adding water and 40 fish all within a week. They then lived through a horrible Ich outbreak.
They are my little troopers and cant get rid of them now lol

Oh well
 
Well, I absolutely love my Mollys, just wanted a school or 2 to fill the "gap" so to speak. If I cant add anything too them Ill just have to forget adding anything.

A little upsetting but I cant give them up. 3 of them lived through me adding water and 40 fish all within a week. They then lived through a horrible Ich outbreak.
They are my little troopers and cant get rid of them now lol

Oh well

You could add the schools no problem. And instead of a dwarf gourami you could probably do a larger kind of gourami.

I was just telling you that your stocking level is so high because you have so many Molly's.
 
Oh!! Well thats the best news Ive gotten all day! Hah

Can I add a larger one? I thought they got too large for my tank. I have a 40g corner.
He wont pick on the smaller fish?
 
What about a honey one? Im looking for a little color here and there. I have mostly black and white fish, the exception being 2 creamsicle mollys and the dark green on my corys.
 
What about a honey one? Im looking for a little color here and there. I have mostly black and white fish, the exception being 2 creamsicle mollys and the dark green on my corys.

The Mollies may bully a Honey Gourami. They can be quite pushy. I consider Mollies Semi Aggressive. Not all Mollies, but many can be bullies, esp around food.

I wouldn't add more fish unless you add plants and perhaps a bigger filter. But pushing your tank limits also puts your fish at risk for diseases and other issues. Mollies have a much bigger bioload for their size. Most Livebearers do, messy fish.
Your Cories also aren't Cories, they are Brochis splendens a cousin. They get bigger than most dwarf Cories.

If you want to add more fish consider moving 1/2 the Mollies elsewhere.

Plants can add color and life also ;)
 
Back
Top Bottom