Well it ended up recovering 105 files... some of which of course were pictures that I still actually had on my card.
Out of all those, it only succesfully recovered 2 of the pictures 100% and one more about 95%. So I'm happy about that, but it didn't recover any of the ones that I really wanted.
I wish I had posted about this months ago when this happened. Like I said I tried 5+ different programs, but even being the day that it happened, they didn't recover ANY of the pictures 100%. So I think I would have had more luck.
Well thanks for the help guys. I'll just be happy to have the 2.95 pics.