Originally Posted by MrPillow
It could amount to different heights used vs circular competitors in the same product market. Who knows. Either way, the concept is mathematically sound. Unless someone is going to take a Fluval from every line, and get an example of its direct competitors which are circular and produce roughly the same GPH
rating, and directly measure the volumes for all examples involved, "proving" its not a lie isnt going to happen.
Exactly, any more then proving it is a lie. Very difficult to prove negatives.
BTW they are not making the comparison to any real competitive product, only hypothetical ones that could exit if they were the same 'outside dimensions'.
If they actually had a media area advantage over competitive products, I would think they would just state that.
Anyway, its is really not about short comings or advantages of the product, only the slick marketing words used to try and sell it.
EDIT: I am referencing internal dimensions here, as external dimensions are clearly stated to be identical by Fluval. Perhaps the "trickery" is some sort of design which allows to maximize useable internal volume?
Yeah, if this mythical competitive product had 1/2 inch thick walls, perhaps it could get there. And my truck can go 180 mph too (with 120 mph wind behind it), wanna buy it?