Batt4Christ
Aquarium Advice FINatic
- Joined
- Apr 18, 2011
- Messages
- 634
Watts per gallon is pretty meaningless for anything but the old T8 standard lights.
Depending on the bulb manufacturer, T5HO can be anywhere from 50%-100% "more" than T8 bulbs. But again - a direct comparison is difficult.
What I do know - not only wattage/light output, but also length of photo period (how long lights are on) is important to consider. My fixture (on 55g tank) has 3 tubes - 48" T5 HO. If I were to run all three for 10 hours a day (total of 162 watts of T5HO) - I would be so overrun with algae, I would probably feel like quitting the hobby! I run 1 tube for 14 hours, and all three for 5 hours (to simulate mid-day sun). Even with my CO2 running, I have patches of Black Beard Algae (BBA) on some hard surfaces. It was much worse before I allowed Salvinia to cover most of the surface (along with Dwarf Water Lilly). The cover plants both help block excess light, and also "consume" excess Nitrates (the two biggest contributors to algae growth).
I have never owned a 40b tank (though it is on my list - I love the dimensions), It isn't as deep as my 55g. 2 T5 HO bulbs would be pretty high light.
The fixture you have - I'm not sure how you get 200 watts with a 36" T5 HO. Those are usually 39 watts each. Assuming that is correct - Just two tubes on at a time would be plenty of light for most cases. A third tube on for a short time wouldn't hurt too bad... assuming you don't light the tank 14 hours a day.
Can you control individual bulbs, or are they either all on or all off?
Depending on the bulb manufacturer, T5HO can be anywhere from 50%-100% "more" than T8 bulbs. But again - a direct comparison is difficult.
What I do know - not only wattage/light output, but also length of photo period (how long lights are on) is important to consider. My fixture (on 55g tank) has 3 tubes - 48" T5 HO. If I were to run all three for 10 hours a day (total of 162 watts of T5HO) - I would be so overrun with algae, I would probably feel like quitting the hobby! I run 1 tube for 14 hours, and all three for 5 hours (to simulate mid-day sun). Even with my CO2 running, I have patches of Black Beard Algae (BBA) on some hard surfaces. It was much worse before I allowed Salvinia to cover most of the surface (along with Dwarf Water Lilly). The cover plants both help block excess light, and also "consume" excess Nitrates (the two biggest contributors to algae growth).
I have never owned a 40b tank (though it is on my list - I love the dimensions), It isn't as deep as my 55g. 2 T5 HO bulbs would be pretty high light.
The fixture you have - I'm not sure how you get 200 watts with a 36" T5 HO. Those are usually 39 watts each. Assuming that is correct - Just two tubes on at a time would be plenty of light for most cases. A third tube on for a short time wouldn't hurt too bad... assuming you don't light the tank 14 hours a day.
Can you control individual bulbs, or are they either all on or all off?