Worst untrue aquarium myth?

The friendliest place on the web for anyone with an interest in aquariums or fish keeping!
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
Well you really don't if you're willing to let the water sit and gas out.

Sent from my 5560S using Aquarium Advice mobile app

I would watch him. Change his fish water. Straight out of the tap into the tank. No gas out period nothing. Washed down the cannister filter with tap water as well.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-N900A using Aquarium Advice mobile app
 
Worst untrue aquarium myth?....Hmmmmm
If it's on the internet or a webpage, it must be true! :facepalm::banghead::blink:

Followed by "Tanks can fully cycle in a day." :facepalm:
 
I would watch him. Change his fish water. Straight out of the tap into the tank. No gas out period nothing. Washed down the cannister filter with tap water as well.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-N900A using Aquarium Advice mobile app

Yeah no conditioner in the tank is no good, but rinsing filters in tap water isn't going to kill enough bacteria to make a difference really.

Sent from my 5560S using Aquarium Advice mobile app
 
That goldfish can live in bowls! How many people still believe that ??




Sent from my bed, the only space available to me that isn't smothered in dirty laundry or aquariums.
 
Maybe we should also post what the facts are, to better explain why the myths are in fact, untrue.?

^This^

Lets not just answer,lets discuss what the real deal is.
Some myths ,like many facts can have an exception.
The inch per gallon is pretty good if you are keeping neons,or cardinals.
10 neons in 10g,not best,not worst IMO.
10" Oscar in a 10g?

Lets discuss why the myth exist,or the misunderstanding behind them?

What about you can't change 100% water!!!!
 
A good one from my wife (user missgurnus): "You need to change out your filter media at least once a month!"

Explanation? Filter companies want more $$$$

^This^

Lets not just answer,lets discuss what the real deal is.
Some myths ,like many facts can have an exception.
The inch per gallon is pretty good if you are keeping neons,or cardinals.
10 neons in 10g,not best,not worst IMO.
10" Oscar in a 10g?

Lets discuss why the myth exist,or the misunderstanding behind them?

What about you can't change 100% water!!!!

The problem is that the rule doesn't give any hint or nuance to stocking. It works in such limited scenarios that it's almost worthless. It's good for 2 inch fish with a body shape like that of a neon. But then you have 3 to 4 inch fish like kuhli loaches that are long and thin and have a tiny bioload. A 12" spiny eel has much less bioload than a 12" oscar, which is much different than three 4" rainbowfish, four 3" platys, or six 2" neons. It also doesn't take into account diet- herbivorous fish tend to produce a lot more waste than carnivorous fish.

Ultimately the problem with this rule is that it enables people to stock their tank with minimal research- just add up the maximum sizes of the fish. Throwing that rule out the window forces people to research the diet, bioload and activity level of the fish in order to stock properly. It's a shortcut that leads to general fishkeeping ignorance (and in many cases actually badly limits stocking).

Most of my tanks debunk this rule pretty badly:
20 gallon "south american": five corydoras and fifteen glowlights. 45" of adult fish
20 gallon shellie: 15 adult 2" multies and a lot of babies. 30" of fish
29 gallon angelfish pair: 2 angelfish. Adult size 5"; 10" of fish
55 gallon community: (planned stocking) 1 angelfish, 5 platys, 5 kuhli loaches, 5 yoyo loaches, 5 angelicus loaches. A whopping 90" of adult fish!


I think that "you can't change 100% water" is true on a technical level- to actually do a 100% water change you'd have to remove the fish and substrate and completely dry out the tank, which IS generally not a recommended thing to do unless you're completely overhauling something.
 
Last edited:
Well, i think its because a lot of people are told by the people higher up to say that, so they can sell a bit more...


Sent from my bed, the only space available to me that isn't smothered in dirty laundry or aquariums.
 
Mostly a myth, with some exceptions: you should add chemicals to get the "perfect" pH for your fish.
 
Nutrients cause algae.......... THEY DONT!


Sent from my iPhone using Aquarium Advice

They do in sw


Sent from my iPhone using Aquarium Advice

Actually, they don't.:nono: They FEED the algae but do not CAUSE the algae. Algae spores are everywhere in the water ( fresh, salt, tap, well, ocean, land) and just need the proper environment for them to grow into the wonderful colored messes we all hate. ( Grrrr) So I think Sk3lly gets this one because of the word "cause". (y)
 
Mostly a myth, with some exceptions: you should add chemicals to get the "perfect" pH for your fish.
(y)

"Chasing the perfect pH"....
This without much exception has to confuse most new keepers IMO.
Once you understand water chemistry ph is not what you will chase any ways!
Almost every fish sold at a pet whatever will do fine in your own source water with less issue then the temp you keep your tank.
The temp you keep tropical is all the same basically anyways right?
Fortunately many have the knowledge to explain the proper way to get "unruly" water in line but it is not through the stuff the LFS sells to change ph!!
 
(y)

"Chasing the perfect pH"....
This without much exception has to confuse most new keepers IMO.
Once you understand water chemistry ph is not what you will chase any ways!
Almost every fish sold at a pet whatever will do fine in your own source water with less issue then the temp you keep your tank.
The temp you keep tropical is all the same basically anyways right?
Fortunately many have the knowledge to explain the proper way to get "unruly" water in line but it is not through the stuff the LFS sells to change ph!!

Yes ph is completely irrelevant anyway. Tds is king!

Sent from my 5560S using Aquarium Advice mobile app
 
Yes ph is completely irrelevant anyway. Tds is king!

Sent from my 5560S using Aquarium Advice mobile app

Maybe more of a combination of TDS, GH and KH. You can technically have a high TDS and a high GH but if your KH is too low you're gonna have a real bad time.
 
^This^

Lets not just answer,lets discuss what the real deal is.
Some myths ,like many facts can have an exception.
The inch per gallon is pretty good if you are keeping neons,or cardinals.
10 neons in 10g,not best,not worst IMO.
10" Oscar in a 10g?

Lets discuss why the myth exist,or the misunderstanding behind them?


I have wondered where this came from. I think aqadvisor or some other site gives a bit of detail of the history which I found fascinating.

I get it to work in my DT however it is modified. I couldn't even really explain how I modify it because as pointed out above, there's body shape, etc, etc to consider. One that I did like about it was that it was (most of the time) including finage but importantly was adult size. I have dim recollection of that being explained to me that 'yes, fish do really grow and thus, no more goldfish for you (unless we can interest you in a second tank)'.

Here in Australia I rarely see this rule or guideline pop up now (maybe the metric conversion doesn't work so well :) ). I've never read it within an aquarium book for some time.

However misinformation on way to high goldfish stocking rates by something like every 5 gallons is still out there. Actually come to think of it - most books I have read, skip stocking rates completely (will have to double-check that).
 
Here in Australia I rarely see this rule or guideline pop up now (maybe the metric conversion doesn't work so well :) ). I've never read it within an aquarium book for some time.

I overheard a woman say it in petsmart yesterday and I gave her a biology lesson.... whoops :angel: (My wife wasn't there to stop me from trying to lecture people like she usually does...)
 
Yeah sw isn't to bad. Just expensive. I'd rather mix saltwater and test more often than gravel vac and deal with plants :). Ugh plants...


Sent from my iPhone using Aquarium Advice


Lol - yes, I know what you mean! I no longer even know if I have fish (except when I see them eating the plants grr!)
 
Back
Top Bottom