Gravel vs Sand

[Oscarr19]

Which is better for planted tank? I currently have gravel but want to switch to pool filter sand. I've heard it is better for planted tank. True?

 

[Fishguy2727]

Yes. Plants root better in sand.

I prefer Estes' Marine Sand, now called Stoney River. It comes in multiple color options and is very uniform in size.

 

[Oscarr19]

I assume that sand isn't as cheap as pfs right?

 

[Fishguy2727]

No, it runs about the same cost as gravel though and I wouldn't trust anything else.

 

[Oscarr19]

Well i just picked up pool filter sand...or so i thought. The guy gave me the wrong bag. Gave me some other filtration substance. Taking it back tomorrow for the right stuff. Anyways thanks for your help.

 

[fadetoblack06]

So did you get out and get the right stuff Oscarr19? If so how did it go with the changing. I hope what I suggested worked out for you with the sand in the pillow case and the shower parts.

 

[Oscarr19]

i'm going to exchange the sand today. I'll be doing the 5G tomorrow and hopefully the 32G by thursday.

 

[Kolmar]

Can you put an air stone or wall in the sand?
Or is there anything else youcan had to create bubbles?

 

[Oscarr19]

an air stone is fine but you don't need one if you filter is agitating the water enough.

 

[Batt4Christ]

Pfs should be fine and is a lot better than gravel for plants. What kind of stuff did the guy give you?

 

[Davidsoccer22]

I like the look of gravel better so I planted my plants in sand and then put four kilos of gravel on top

 

[Kolmar]

an air stone is fine but you don't need one if you filter is agitating the water enough.

Thanks, it's more for the looks than the air actually.