My experience with them is limited to e-mail correspondance and phone conversations, but for me, that was enough. I live in the same town that they do, but they insist on shipping to me for $14. They use a same-day courier service, but pack the fish up the night before, and when I wondered if they packed the fish (especially delicate ones) the same day, they said no, they packed them the night before. Then they told me that it was the same amount of stress on the fish for me to come up, get them, and drive them home (a 15 minute trip) as it was for the fish to be boxed, sit in the box all night, then come by courier.
Their policies are questionable, the tone on their website is unprofessional and condescending, and I just can't convince myself to order from them. I'm really glad to hear that some people are having good luck with them, however.