Do fish loose their scales?

The friendliest place on the web for anyone with an interest in aquariums or fish keeping!
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.

FriscoTX

Aquarium Advice Regular
Joined
Feb 27, 2006
Messages
98
Location
Frisco, TX
Is it normal for a fish to loose some of its scales? I've noticed that my goldie is loosing her/his scales. I thought at first that it was because of a near 100% water change and must've scrapped on something during the change. But it appears that it isn't getting better & it looks as is if both sides of his/her body are affected, whereas before it was noticeable on just the right side. I haven't observed any of the scraping behavior sometimes discussed on this forum.

Coupled with the fact that the fish hasn't been observed eating in the past week - I'm wondering if I'm not doing something right.
 
Is the fish at all bloated?

I'm not sure what's wrong with him, but if you have a QT, he needs to get in there now. Primary treatment for any disease is clean water, so get him in the QT and do large water changes regularly. I'd be tempted to start with an antibiotic course. Even if he doesn't have an infection, the lost scales may be indicative of skin damage, and that will allow secondary infection. Close observation might provide a more definitive diagnosis.
 
Larger goldfish can lose one or two of their scales. Normally due to abrasions. Not on both sides. Do the areas look fuzzy or cottony? Are any of the scales raised and does the goldy seem bloated? The fact that he is not eating is the worrisome part IMO. He may have scraped himself during the water change and is now getting infected.
 
Check all of your ornaments (logs, ships, etc) for rough edges and size compared to the fish. I have an oranda that still hasn't regrown all of his scales when he got stuck in a log... I had him in QT for 3-4 months because he actually lost a little fillet on his side when we finally got him out. We never thought he'd attempt to go into that log because he is so much bigger than it is, but he did. He's fine now, and back with his goldfish friends but, I don't think the scales will ever grow back especially on the side where he lost the meat - it's scarred. Also, watch the behaviour of other fish in the tank. We had a guppie that was a loner from taking over my mother's fishstock... seemed like the goldfish tank was the only place for him... then we noticed he was pulling scales off of the gentle goldfish! I promptly moved him to my rainbow tank thinking he would either go into hiding amongst the plants or be killed by the rainbows. Unbelievably, the rainbows have accepted him and he's quite happy in there. Also, he could be rubbing intentionally on objects in the tank either due to a parasite on the skin or too many ornaments and not enough room to swim. Or, he could have rubbed himself on something during the drastic water change. There are several things that could have happened. QT is definitely good advice but, check all of those other things too. Hope your guy returns to full health soon.
 
I already have him in a 10g by himself; so he's QT'd. Here are some pics:

Sharktaleright.jpg

Sharktaleleft.jpg
 
I'd start with adding some melafix to the water to assist in repairing the scale damage. Also try feeding some frozen peas rather than his regular food to make sure he isn't constipated.
 
he isn't eating, I tried the peas not too long ago - but I'll give it another shot. If I'm not mistaken Melafix is an antibacterial treatment. The tank is in the middle of it's cycle - taking a long time - so I want to be careful about what I add to the water.

Not sure what I can do at this point, the fish won't eat and it's lossing scales, things don't look so good....
 
Melafix is mild and will not harm the cycle. Take any active carbon out of the filter. Are you able to hand feed him the peas at all? Make sure they are bite size.
 
The last time I tried to feed the peas, I squashed the inside out of the husk and let it fall to the bottom. He/She's a skiddish fish, so I doubt I could get it to eat from my hand. But I'm going to give it a shot and see what happens.
 
could be, I took care of my brothers goldfish one time after horrible ammonia burns, it was so bad that mucus had covered over it eyes and fin rott took in
 
Lots of water changes and melafix should be a good treatment plan for a wide variety of problems. Zagz is right.
 
I was out of town, so just now catching up. The fish is still kicking, I just can't decide if I want to spend more money on it - I'll go the water change route for sure, is Melafix expensive?
 
Thanks flipz

Oh btw, the water parameters are:

Ammonia 1.5
Nitrite 0
Nitrate 0
PH 7.8

I've been cycling the tank for 2 weeks and no significant change in the ammonia, very frustrating.
 
I don't think 1.5 would be enough to cause any visible burns on a scaled fish... but it is no doubt uncomfortable. You are right at the point that you might want to consider doing a water change.

Doing so may slow down the cycle (which it seems you are having that problem anyways) but while ammonia burns may not be visible, 1.5 ppm is pretty high and the fish can for sure feel it (assuming fish feel pain). 2 weeks isn't extraordinarly long, wait it out and you should see some nitrite spikes soon! :) Keep up with the water changes, even if you don't invest in the melafix.

-brent
 
When cycling with fish, try to keep the ammonia below .5. It does take a long time, but will greatly increase the chances of survival. Especially with the wounds on your goldie, he needs better quality water to heal.

Have you tried Prime or Amquel+? They will detoxify the ammonia and make it more tolerable to live in. When I've had to cycle a QT with fish, I did water changes to keep ammonia down to .25-.5, and added prime to neturalize the remaining.
 
I haven't tried either of those. I've used an Ammo Blocker and Ammonia nuetralizer in my tap water treatment. Both gave me very inaccurate readings (almost 1-2.0 higher than what was really in the water). I've sinced stopped using the conditioners and am only using the tap water treatment with PWC. I'll do another PWC and see if I can get it .5

I may need to get another test kit, I'm not sure but mine may be a nessler based kit. I'm not sure how to tell to be honest - it uses 2 solutions to test for Ammonia
 
Back
Top Bottom