First New Fish Dead

[Nat_a126]

Originally Posted by mr_X

Send your water out to be tested.

This guy is coming to check out what happening. If that doesn't work out that's what I'm planing to do

[mr_X]

I'm talking about to a lab- not a fish guy.

[Nat_a126]

Originally Posted by mr_X

I'm talking about to a lab- not a fish guy.

Yeah I said if the fish guy can't fix the problem, I'm going to go to a lab

[J8kpin]

Maybe its uncured live rock or live sand, this is really bizzare...

[Fishman007]

Live sand doesnt need to be cured

[J8kpin]

It may have pollutants in there, im just speculating at this point.

[Nat_a126]

Originally Posted by Fishman007

Live sand doesnt need to be cured

Originally Posted by J8kpin

Maybe its uncured live rock or live sand, this is really bizzare...

The rock is already cured. This fish man came today and he said that he is going to bring something that instantly cycles the tank (even though it's been cycled before) and that fish stores tend to keep the salinity low, so I would have to acclimate them for about two hours, depending on how big the difference is. And I'm gonna get chromis from a different store on Wednesday so wish me luck! 😁😄

[mr_X]

I find it hard to believe a single chromis is making that much ammonia in a few hours to kill it. Especially since your testing has shown zero ammonia.

[Nat_a126]

Originally Posted by mr_X

I find it hard to believe a single chromis is making that much ammonia in a few hours to kill it. Especially since your testing has shown zero ammonia.

Yeah but I have no idea what else it could be that's killing them 😓

[Fishman007]

Originally Posted by mr_X

I find it hard to believe a single chromis is making that much ammonia in a few hours to kill it. Especially since your testing has shown zero ammonia.

I meant with the 3 in there, i guess your right about the 1

[Fishman007]

Test the water from the lfs after acclimating to see if there was ammonia

[Nat_a126]

Originally Posted by Fishman007

Test the water from the lfs after acclimating to see if there was ammonia

Okay I will when he comes next week

[mr_X]

From what i understand, a seemingly perfectly healthy fish while at the LFS, makes it's way into the OP's tank and then dies in a short time. I would look to the OP's tank, and not the store it was bought from. I think it pretty much rules out that it was the store's fault.

[Nat_a126]

Originally Posted by mr_X

From what i understand, a seemingly perfectly healthy fish while at the LFS, makes it's way into the OP's tank and then dies in a short time. I would look to the OP's tank, and not the store it was bought from. I think it pretty much rules out that it was the store's fault.

Well yea that's what we are looking into anyways. And I'm going to get the chromis from a different place this time, just in case.

[mr_X]

I'm just saying that i doubt the LFS's water is the culprit.

[Nat_a126]

Originally Posted by mr_X

I'm just saying that i doubt the LFS's water is the culprit.

Oh sorry yes I understand Im getting my water tested

[Fishman007]

Originally Posted by mr_X

I'm just saying that i doubt the LFS's water is the culprit.

I mean to see if ammonia built up after acclimating...

[KeithFrancis]

Any updates Nat?

[Nat_a126]

Originally Posted by KeithFrancis

Any updates Nat?

The guy is coming Monday so I'll let you all know then Wish me luck!

[Nat_a126]

Update: okay so my dad was trying to make the sump quieter. He was attempting to get rid of the vibration of the pump, but ended up breaking the top part of the plexiglass of the sump that stops the water from splashing all over the wood. So that means the pump has to be off for a few days until we can find a place that sells plexiglass that is safe for aquariums :P I put an air stone in the water so it doesn't turn stagnate. Do you guys know any safe plexiglass to use by any chance?