sump vs refugium - which first

[Serpentman]

I am almost finished with phase one (lights, skimmer, LR) of my setup. My next step as I have mentioned in another thread, is to add a refugium and a sump. Because of the weird shape (92g corner) I am believe I will be doing a HOB refugium and a 20H sump due to space restrictions.

I am looking to add the additional equipment over the next 2 months. In your opinion, which should have priority: Sump or refugium.

My gut says the refugium but I would like to hear additional opinions.

 

[canyon15]

I would go with a sump first as it will add a greater volume of water to your whole system, it gives a place to put your unsightly things like heaters and skimmers as well as when you do water changes you don't have to disturb the DT. Thats my 2 cents worth. HTH.

 

[Brenden]

I agree with doing a sump first. Not sure I do not agree with the more water volume than a fuge (if done right) but it makes a good place to hide heaters etc. Also great place for top off water, skimmer, etc.

 

[ryguy]

You can also maximize your return flow to enable a greater net tank turnover with the sump, whereas the fuge needs a lower gph flow through it to fully achieve its goal and avoid disruption.

Go with the sump or incorporate a fuge inside the sump.

 

[Guest]

sump