I looked at my spare impeller, and the inside of it looks perfectly smooth, so yours might be defective. Also, my eheim wasn't perfectly silent, until after a few days, when it built a 'slime' coat on it... but it was making more of a humming noise, no rattle/vibration.
Were your c3's louder? They sounded louder. When mine's running, and you're standing really close to it focusing on it, it sounds like a very quiet fridge running. As long as there isn't any rattling or air noises, which i really couldn't hear, it sounds normal. And after a few days when it gets a 'slime coat', it should be quieter. My 2213 is just as quiet, if not more so, than my AC20