Lost Fish to Power Outage - looking for advice for what I *should* have done

The friendliest place on the web for anyone with an interest in aquariums or fish keeping!
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.

Bent Needle

Aquarium Advice Regular
Joined
Nov 23, 2012
Messages
84
Location
Roanoke, VA
Please don't come after me by saying I should have been prepared for this. I'm well aware. I am absolutely sick at losing my beloved water puppies, ok? So what happened:

Tank stats:
55 gallon, fluval gravel substrate, all artificial decor
2 adult angelfish
1 female adult red spotted severum
1 chinese algae eater
(No, not ideal stocking, but I inherited the tank and kept all but the most obviously wrong occupant, which was a common pleco that was HUGE - but that's been gone for over a year)
It was well established, the severum was laying eggs every few weeks (sadly I only had the one! so all her dutiful watchfulness and care of the eggs was in vain).
Temp: 74-75 degrees Fahrenheit
Ammonia: 0 ppm
Nitrates: ~20 ppm depending on when I last did a water change.

TL;DR: What *should* I have done and what's the best thing to do to avoid this in the future, if I decide to restock my tank? Is there anything I can do for the last fish?

Due to the recent winter storms that came through Virginia, I was without power for almost three days. I will say, I live in a city and in all the almost 10 years I've lived here, I've never lost power for more than a few hours, so I had no backup for my tank equipment. I was aerating the water by hand as often as I could, as I still had to go to work, and otherwise keeping the tank wrapped up in blankets to try and keep the temp as high as possible. Unfortunately, it got to 43 degrees in my house and I'm sure almost as cold in the tank. When the power finally came back on last night the severum and one angelfish were obviously deceased. The algae eater seemed ok but I guess as the temperture rose it went a bit crazy and I honestly think it injured itself by whacking into the glass, and died. The last angelfish I thought was also deceased, as it was lying flat on the bottom of the tank, but as the temp went back up it started flopping around. It's now nose down in a corner of the tank, alive but clearly in trouble. Ammonia was up a bit (like to .25 ppm) this morning, I did a partial water change - and also did a massive one last night after removing the dead fish. I don't usually change more than 30-40% of the water at a time, but it had been so long and I was in such a rush I didn't take time to see where the ammonia was.

I'm pretty sure my last angel is a lost cause, but I'm monitoring the water parameters closely. Any advice? I've got a battery power source on it's way, not that it's going to do any good now, but this shouldn't happen again. I'm so sad. My only small comfort is the water was cold so I don't think they really suffered (except maybe the algae eater, poor thing). 😢😢😢
 
It may be too late for the most effected fish but the only thing you can do for them is making sure their water is as clean as possible. If the tank got too cold, the temperature needs to be raised slowly to not effect the fish so that may have been the cause of the algae eater's response and the Angel's response.
As for the backup, there us a Battery operated air pump that plugs into the wall ( https://www.amazon.com/PENN-PLAX-Si...=1015214&hvtargid=pla-354822197491&th=1&psc=1 ) so that it only comes on when the power goes off vs plain battery operated air pumps that need someone to turn them on. Think of it in terms of the power going off in the middle of the night. If you are not awake and only have the non electric battery operated pump, that's a problem. The air pump I linked solves that problem. The only thing you need to do is routinely check the batteries for strength. ( Just unplug from the wall and it should go on. (y) ) What kind of filtration are you using? In something like a HOB filter, using a gang valve to split the air line, you can place an air stone inside the filter box so that should the power go out, the aeration in the filter box will keep the nitrifying microbes alive until the power goes back on. Obviously this will not work in a canister style filter.

Hope this helps. (y)
 
Thank you for the recommendation. I have not lost fish like this before...is it most likely the lack of consistent oxygen that killed them? Or the cold temp? The water was probably at least 50 degrees Fahrenheit.

In possibly positive news, the one surviving angel is having moments of swimming upright today. It mostly rests near the bottom, but that's also mostly upright now, instead of laying completely prone. I don't know if I'm hopeful yet but I feel like it's okay to let it try for another day. Last night I was considering euthanizing it because it was just laying there - but it didn't seem to be truly struggling.
 
Thank you for the recommendation. I have not lost fish like this before...is it most likely the lack of consistent oxygen that killed them? Or the cold temp? The water was probably at least 50 degrees Fahrenheit.

In possibly positive news, the one surviving angel is having moments of swimming upright today. It mostly rests near the bottom, but that's also mostly upright now, instead of laying completely prone. I don't know if I'm hopeful yet but I feel like it's okay to let it try for another day. Last night I was considering euthanizing it because it was just laying there - but it didn't seem to be truly struggling.
I would definitely not euthanize this fish. It needs a chance to have it's body parts start to recirculate the blood flow. Many years ago in a small holding station I had, we had a freeze in Florida and our heat went out and our marine fish literally went into a state of hypothermia. They looked catatonic. ( It was really spooky to see btw. ;) ) My partner and I could nothing until the heat was fixed. Once that was done, it took almost 2 weeks to get the water temp high enough for the fish to come back to life. Bottom line tho was that all the fish survived so you have to give the fish a chance. (y)
 
Oh my gosh. I really hope I didn't remove any still living fish! But the ammonia levels had risen in the tank (I assumed from the deceased fish), and I watched them for a very long time, there was no movement at all from gills or fins or anything. This was the only one with any signs of life, and I honestly thought it was also deceased at first, but then its gills were fluttering just a tiny bit.

So it's normal for them to take a few days to recover? It's only been about a day and a half. Also I'm guessing I raised the temp WAY too quickly (over a few hours) if it took you 2 weeks to bring it back. How slowly should I have done it?
 
Oh my gosh. I really hope I didn't remove any still living fish! But the ammonia levels had risen in the tank (I assumed from the deceased fish), and I watched them for a very long time, there was no movement at all from gills or fins or anything. This was the only one with any signs of life, and I honestly thought it was also deceased at first, but then its gills were fluttering just a tiny bit.

So it's normal for them to take a few days to recover? It's only been about a day and a half. Also I'm guessing I raised the temp WAY too quickly (over a few hours) if it took you 2 weeks to bring it back. How slowly should I have done it?
We did about 2 degrees per 12 hours. I know some places online say 1-2 degrees per hour but we didn't lose anything so extending the time did not have any bad effects.
As for tossing the other fish, it's too late now to do anything about that but usually, even with them being that cold, you should have seen some gill movement. (y)
 
We did about 2 degrees per 12 hours. I know some places online say 1-2 degrees per hour but we didn't lose anything so extending the time did not have any bad effects.
As for tossing the other fish, it's too late now to do anything about that but usually, even with them being that cold, you should have seen some gill movement. (y)
Yikes! Well damn. Definitely WAY too fast on the temp. Hopefully there won't be a next time, but I'll know now.

I'm positive there wasn't gill movement, at least. I'm not going to let myself consider the other option. 😞
 
Yikes! Well damn. Definitely WAY too fast on the temp. Hopefully there won't be a next time, but I'll know now.

I'm positive there wasn't gill movement, at least. I'm not going to let myself consider the other option. 😞
Then it's 99.99999999999999999999999% ( because nothing is 100% when you have a question about it. ;) ) true you did the right thing. (y)
 
You wrote " I've got a battery power source on it's way" What did you get? I use a UPS on my computers but can move it to the aquarium when needed plus I use the air pump that Andy mentioned (he told me about it last year) and it works great. The good thing about the ups is I can run the heater off of it. It all depends on your equipment as to what and how long it will keep your stuff going and the size of the ups. One thing for long term outages you may need a backup heater because you don't have your normal room temp your tank heater has to work a lot more and may not be able to keep up with demand. If you ever decide to go this route I can help you with how to size it for your needs. I have to admit I have a large generator after a hour or two my wife wants her stuff working the good thing is when it is running I'm recharging the ups,laptops,phones,tablets and all the other crap we can not live without any more.:( Plan C is plenty of firewood food water and ammo not in that order;)
 
Back
Top Bottom