Well I ended up transferring the 4 glo moon tetras into the 55g tank and they immediately were more active schooling around.
I then figured it would be a good time to go check the stock at my LFS.
I met an incredible worker there by the name of Dave. He helped me with all of the things that you helpful folks have said from day 1. I explained to him the situation and he felt it would be ok for me to add the guppies I wanted as well as 4 more glo moon tetras.. let me explain
He gave me his personal phone number, and a bottle of api stress coat for free, a piece of airline tubing and showed me how to do a slow drip introduction.
Said if I had any issues to shoot him a text and he would gladly help... He also said to save the fish bags, as well as my receipt just in case. because petco has their 30 day guarantee.
SO... with that being said, my tank now has 8 glo moon tetras, and 7 guppies.
What would you recommend next? the black kuhli loaches?
I was thinking 6 loaches, 2 GBR's and that gives me room for a few more fish.. any suggestions?