Help with substrate change

The friendliest place on the web for anyone with an interest in aquariums or fish keeping!
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.

MINIMAL

Aquarium Advice Freak
Joined
May 20, 2015
Messages
202
Location
Charleston, WV
Ok so I need some help deciding what to do. I have a 55g heavily planted that I plan to remove a lot of stemmed plants from and try to get some carpet plants going. The issue is that I did not plan for carpet in the beginning and used pea gravel mixed with a little crushed lava rock. While it has worked amazing for the stemmed plants, however the carpet plants are only attaching to the exposed areas where lava rock is, the rest is not spreading or growing at all due to lack of surface porosity. With that being said I need to change out the substrate. I have a 50lb bag of Turface MVP ready to go, but I am undecided on how to handle the swap. So here are the ideas I have so far.

1. Drain 75% of the water, remove plants and driftwood and clean the top 1" layer of substrate while draining. Remove 1" of the pea gravel, and place the plants back in and fill to desired level with turface. Replace water and let UV sterilizer run for 36 hours to combat chances of algae bloom. Possible issues: Turface will settle and the pea gravel will eventually work its way to the top layer as there will still be 1-2" of pea gravel under the turface.

2. Drain 75% of water, remove plants, clean all areas around driftwood and rocks and remove all substate that does not have driftwood/rocks on top. Replace these entire areas with turface. Replace water and let UV sterilizer run for 36 hours to combat chances of algae bloom. Possible issues: Will this upset the biological filter too much? (roughly 1/2 of surface is covered by rock or driftwood that will not be removed)

3. Remove fish into buckets of tank water, completely drain, remove all substrate, and replace with turface, replace plants and decor. Issues: This will be extemely time consuming, will not leave any biological filter inside the tank, and I will need to schedule several appointments with a chiropractor for 2-3 weeks afterwards.

Which of these sounds like the best idea, or does anybody else have a better suggestion? I was thinking about just covering the top layer with turface at first, but as much as I move plants, and the aquatic life shifts substrate, it would disappear in no time, as the crushed lava rock did. My tank is understocked greatly as far as fish go. For those that dont know, turface is basically flourite without mineralization, but with the high CEC value, it wont take long to begin storing minerals for plant consumption....oh and it was only $9.95 for a 50# bag vs. Flourite that is $25+ for a 14# bag.... Thanks in advance for any advice you can give! I am sure there will be 1 or 2 people who perform a public roasting, there always is so I'll just enjoy my popcorn lol :popcorn::lol::popcorn::fish2:
 
Curious what the suggestions are on this, as I am doing a complete overhaul on my tank as well as soon as my new plants get in. Subscribed and following. Good luck with the 55 gallon change, mine is only 10 :). My biggest worry is losing all the good bacteria and having to go through a cycle again.
 
Curious what the suggestions are on this, as I am doing a complete overhaul on my tank as well as soon as my new plants get in. Subscribed and following. Good luck with the 55 gallon change, mine is only 10 :). My biggest worry is losing all the good bacteria and having to go through a cycle again.

Thanks! I am planning on doing this tonight when I get back in town since I will only be in town for 2 days. So I am hoping advice starts flowing quickly lol.
 
Hey minimal, how ya doing? Them moscows ok.?,Heres how i did it. Get fish out, buckets are fine to put them in. Take out plants, wood, deco etc.... Turn off all filtration and heaters Vacuum tank down 3/4 of the way. Take a 1" ID hose and siphon out your substrate. Wet vac works great too. Replace substrate.

Sent from my SPH-L710 using Aquarium Advice mobile app
 
Hey minimal, how ya doing? Them moscows ok.?,Heres how i did it. Get fish out, buckets are fine to put them in. Take out plants, wood, deco etc.... Turn off all filtration and heaters Vacuum tank down 3/4 of the way. Take a 1" ID hose and siphon out your substrate. Wet vac works great too. Replace substrate.

Sent from my SPH-L710 using Aquarium Advice mobile app

Yep the moscows are doing good.

Sounds easy enough... going to have to find some bigger buckets for all the plants and wood, or a bathtub would suffice I guess.....as long as the wife is asleep or not home haha. I will find something and I will make sure the fish are in a bucket. Not looking forward to catching the khulis or the shrimp though. Last time I moved some plants around I found the khulis in a butterbowl 4 hours after I got done rescaping....guess they had burrowed in one of the stemmed plants roots or something because I never saw them. Caught my eye seconds before they took a ride to the water treatment facility.

I will make sure to get before and after pics.
 
Forgot to post pictures of the substrate change.


Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-N910A using Aquarium Advice mobile app
 

Attachments

  • 1437316333721.jpg
    1437316333721.jpg
    228.7 KB · Views: 94
Don't really got no major advice for you here, sorry. But just jumped in to say good luck, I got the same situation with my 26g. Hope everything works out well for you. Following this.
 
It worked great. It's been up for 10 days now with the new substrate and the growth has increased exponentially. It was a lot quicker than I thought it would be.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-N910A using Aquarium Advice mobile app
 
Oh I made a quick change system too. I can do a 10% wc in about 5 minutes now. Could be 2 if I didn't have plants.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-N910A using Aquarium Advice mobile app
 
Back
Top Bottom