I have read that they will probably be in competition for burrow space. If the tank is large enough, you should be ok, but I would not try this in anything less than a 55. Also, a jaw will require a much deeper substrate bed than a pistol. I have kept pistols on one inch of substrate and they MAKE burrows by moving sand and rocks arround. Jaws require a much deeper bed to make a decent burrow. If you have enough substrate and room so that both can be happy, you should be ok.