Sick Acarichthys Heckelii - Please Help!

The friendliest place on the web for anyone with an interest in aquariums or fish keeping!
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.

confused

Aquarium Advice Newbie
Joined
May 1, 2014
Messages
4
So I'm somewhat new to fish keeping - I had goldfish in the past, and recently switched to a tropical tank. I found a really neat looking fish at my local fish shop, a geophagus heckelii - I bought it, brought it home, and all was fine for 3 weeks. I have a 45 gallon tank with a canister filter, I keep it at 79 degrees, and I have a 12" air stone with a 40 gal pump (which the shop said was fine for my tank). Previous to getting the heckelii, I had 2 x-ray tetras, 2 red-finned tetras, 2 diamond tetras, a bamboo shrimp, 2 dwarf guaramis (1 red, 1 blue), and 2 spotted corys to eat the excess food off the bottom. I got the heckelii and everything was great for 3 weeks - at that time, my local fish shop said that 4-5 jewel cichlids would round my tank out nicely, so I bought 4 jewels this past Saturday. That's when everything went wrong.

My heckelii immediately got territorial and started chasing around the jewels (who don't seem to be the aggressors at all, they run away from the heckelii). He ate an x-ray tetra (I replaced it) and the bamboo shrimp, then ate another x-ray. I returned 2 of the jewels. So currently, my setup is 1 x-ray tetra, 2 dward guaramis (1 of which is currently recovering in a baby breeding net because the red guarami was picking on it and eating its back fin pretty bad), 2 jewels, 2 diamond tetras, 2 red-finned tetras, and 2 spotted corys.

I use well water, the pH is always above 7, my nitrates are the lowest setting on my test (yellow), and I get my water tested at the fish shop regularly - I had a water test last nite, and the shop said everything looked great (in fact, they often use the words "great" or "perfect" and always seem impressed with the water quality). We do water changes every 2 weeks. I don't know the exact parameters of the tests because the store usually does them for me... But they always come out good.

2 days ago, we noticed 2 round things that looked like injuries on his face - I thought maybe hole in the head, but the water quality is fine. Upon doing research, I found that hole in the head can be due to lack of proper vitamins/nutrition. We feed flakes, but after Googling it seemed that maybe he wasn't getting enough (since the heckelii doesn't go up to the surface the same way as the tetras) so I thought maybe the aggression and the head issue was due to that - gave him some shrimp pellets yesterday, and he gobbled them up. I thought problem solved, but then about 2 hours after eating them, he puked - like, a big puff of expanded pellet came out of his mouth... 3 times. Yesterday afternoon after regurgitating (which 1 of the jewels also did), he didn't want to eat - he also didn't eat today. He was flashing yesterday, and broke 1 of the injuries on his head open. I also saw one of my jewels flashing. Not sure if it's territorial, or what - the fish shop says they had the heckelii for over 3 months and the jewels for over a month with no parasites. I haven't added anything new that wasn't from there, just the jewels (before that, everything in my tank was fine). I'm not even sure that it's heavy breathing all the time... It's weird - it's almost like he has something stuck in his throat or something, like he kinda shakes his head and opens his mouth wide and then breathes more normal, but I can see the skin flapping out of his gills (which I normally can't see). He looks uncomfortable, but it seems to have started after he threw up those shrimp pellets (before that, he ate them voraciously, and ate quite a few - I thought maybe the puking was just that they expanded in his belly and came back out, but my loach or goldfish never had any issue with regurgitating and the fish store said shrimp pellets were fine to feed him).

I went to the fish store yesterday, and picked up some Primafix and Melafix - dosed the water yesterday and today. I also picked up some cichlid veggie pellets and tried feeding him those yesterday and today, but he showed 0 interest in eating. I cut up some zucchini and put that in there, no interest in eating. Today, he's spending more time than usual near the top of the tank - he's breathing heavily, and his fins are clamped (like a cat with his ears pinned - he's breathing faster than normal and his gills are flaring more than normal. He's got his dorsal fin pinned to his body, his lower fins pinned up, and his tail fin compressed). My fish shop is at a loss and can't figure out what's wrong, or what to do next - I don't want to lose my fish. Please help!

I've attached some pics - 1 is of the injury on his head, 1 is of that injury split open after he flashed on the gravel, 1 is him with his clamped fins, and 1 is what he looked like when I got him and he seemed happy :(
 

Attachments

  • 20140427_135449_resized.jpg
    20140427_135449_resized.jpg
    191.8 KB · Views: 108
  • 20140429_182705_resized.jpg
    20140429_182705_resized.jpg
    123.3 KB · Views: 140
  • 20140429_193921_resized.jpg
    20140429_193921_resized.jpg
    137.1 KB · Views: 108
  • 20140501_202722_resized.jpg
    20140501_202722_resized.jpg
    115.7 KB · Views: 136
How's he doing? Did the melafix and pimafix make any difference?

The checking but your well water is very consistent in quality?
 
He seems to be feeling a bit better - we did get the kH repeatedly tested (it had been fine virtually every time we tested it, but it was a 4 the last time we tested, so we bought some stuff to balance that out to make sure the pH wasn't fluctuating throughout the day) and we got a new (bigger) airstone, which seemed to make a big difference (the funny part is that I think his fins were clamped because he was pissed at the new airstone - he didn't like it in there, took him a good day to get used to it). He's kinda given up on being the alpha male and cedes to the Jewels (which is funny, because neither of them show any interest in being the alpha). He seems to be happier with fewer in the tank, so I think returning 2 of the Jewels to the pet store was a good move.

But he's still got those injuries, or whatever the heck they are, on his head. The 2 holes have kinda molded into 1 big hole (they used to be clearly separated, and now it's 1 oblong hole instead of 2 circular holes right near each other) and I don't know if that's a good thing or a bad thing. I don't know how hole in the head progresses - the fish store said that hole in the head is usually due to prolonged periods in poor water, which obviously hasn't been the case here. He did start eating again, which is the good news - but I think he's kinda the dumb pretty one in the tank... He's not very good about coming to the surface for flakes, or foraging the gravel for pellets, so I just make sure to time it properly and drop shrimp and veggie pellets right in front of his face after he's done chewing 1, so he's been eating ok. I think he didn't eat for a few days because he was full, but that seems to have corrected itself. The only thing now is the hole in his head... Do you have any ideas as to what that might be?
 
I did wonder on the well water in case that had changed and was causing the flashing. Is it a liquid test they use at the shop? Just thinking it would be good to know those readings exactly even though no reason to doubt lfs when they say good. Are you running any carbon?

I'm not an expert on head problems so really need someone out there that knows more. Do you think the stress could of bought it on or more a fighting injury? Doesn't sound good if it is growing.
 
Yeah, they use liquid - not sure on the exact params otherwise, but this time the kH was a 4 (a couple days prior, and in weeks prior, it always came in at 6-7). He's not flashing anymore. The injury or whatever it is isn't growing - it was 2 separate holes very close to each other, and now they've kinda connected and are just an oval dent in his head. It doesn't appear to be getting worse, but it doesn't seem to be getting better as quick as I'd like either. I used to have some fake coral in the tank (I've since taken it out) that was kinda pokey, and the ends were about the same size as the 2 holes in his head, so I'm wondering if he smacked his head on it. I dunno... Seems weird. I can't figure out what it would be - lfs says no hole in head because water params are too good, so I'm outta ideas :/
 
They pretty much said there was no way it could be HITH because of the good water conditions - I have no idea... It doesn't look as much like an open wound anymore, but it's definitely still there. I tried to get a good pic yesterday, but he wouldn't stay still enough. His tail fin is a bit nipped the last couple days, so I'm wondering if him and the cichlids are getting into it at nite (at which point, it COULD be a fighting injury). I'll try to get another pic today - it looks like it's healing, but it's not getting a lot better quickly. How long do fish injuries (if it was just a fighting/flashing injury) take to heal typically?
 
In the reading I did, stress was another suggestion. Otherwise I can't think of much else as it looks fine on water.

Good news it is healing. I've had several days for nipped fins from fighting to a couple of weeks from ich to get scales back and not look ruffled.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom