Fishperson
Aquarium Advice Addict
Please don't "go" anywhere..it's nice to be able to discuss things without anyone getting upset. I'm sorry, but I'm not a big fan of when people confuse newer hobbyists with the inch per gallon rule, and I did not provide anything close to a ridiculous example, so we just aren't on the same page. I stock rummies like I would any other tetra..no special category there for me. According to your philosophy a 29 gal can only house three platties, which according to my experience, if it's filtered and planted and maintained properly, more of those important stocking variables, can house more than that. We can agree to disagree because your stocking philosophy just doesn't fall in line with mine.
Forgive me if I'm wrong, but I was under the impression this was a newer aquarist I was trying to help educate and inform, so I'm not sure what place continuing a conversation on a topic you feel could be helpful for those more experienced has here.
For the OP instead of debating the weights of fish and going back and forth I will try to be more helpful...I will catch one of my neons and bag it and float the bag in with my rasboras and try to snap a pic of one right next to the tetra. That way you can judge for yourself what kind of size difference there is between the two if you don't have first hand experience with them. If you've only seen pics of chili rasboras online you can't grasp how small they are. I'm not a great photographer but I will try!
What I meant by saying that it is easier for experienced hobbyists to use is that it is easier for those with more experience to judge for those with less experience.
Also, yes, that is where the philosophy falls short . Perhaps twice the length for livebearers mentioned would be a better way to judge it.
Just out of curiousity, how old are your chili rasboras? Because most online sources say that they grow to an inch. Very curious, but I guess most of those are wrong.
Also, what I meant specifically about rummies is that they are very torpedo shaped, and although sometimes grow to 2 inches are actually quite "short" from top to bottom.