Problems are building up! Help?

The friendliest place on the web for anyone with an interest in aquariums or fish keeping!
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.

RachelG

Aquarium Advice Activist
Joined
Aug 10, 2013
Messages
172
Location
California
The night I brought this platy home a few days ago, she sprouted some white fuzzy growth on the sides of her mouth. I treated with pimafix and melafix starting yesterday, and it doesn't look any worse today at least. I also used a fan pointed at the tank, and the temperature has dropped from the awful 85f+ to a comfortable 78f. But now I come home from work and she has ICK all over her tail and dorsal fin. I've seen some white spots on some of my fish before, and i was never sure if it was ick or not...But those always faded after a day or two, and this case is definitely, undoubtedly, and surely a case of full-blown ick. And it looks like the dorsal fin is missing a chunk off of it. It doesn't look like it's torn, red, or black. It's just a rounded missing part. Could this be the beginning of fin rot? She is still breathing hard and flashing on the anubias and driftwood occasionally. If she would stay still I could get a decent picture, but she never stops moving. That's a good sign at least, right?

It's a ten gallon tank, and ammonia, etc. readings are good, has lots of live plants, three cherry shrimp, and two female platy. The other platy looks fine, but has one spot on her tail that may be an ick. How can i go about treating this tank? Any ick medications that won't harm shrimp, plants, bio filter, etc? Would Kordon Ich Attack do the job? I know for sure that one is available at local stores. How about aquarium salt?

Should I remove the cherry shrimp? I have a big plastic water jug and a little top fin filter that I could move the shrimp to, and I could use filter media and maybe some gravel and a plant from the endler tank that is not infected...would that do for a makeshift cycled temporary tank? Or could I just move them to my endler tank and see if they get along with the ghost shrimp? Will shrimp carry the fish diseases and parasites over?
Could I possibly do something akin to a salt-bath for my live plants or shrimp, to make sure no ick parasites are transferred anywhere?

What's ironic is I hear people saying not to buy fish from petsmart, get them from a lfs instead. All the fish I bought from petsmart have been completely healthy since arrival, even if they aren't impressive-looking specimens. In fact, my endlers from petsmart have brightened up in color considerably and are thriving in their tank. Now I buy this blue platy from a fish store that is supposed to be good, she comes down with all kind of illnesses.

I also just paid rent, and I'm almost completely broke. I only have twenty dollars until my next paycheck, and this fish problem is the last thing I need. I'm really frustrated, worried, and about to have a panic attack or something. I'm starting to think I should just put the fish down and quit on this tank. At least I'd still have my endler and betta tanks. But i don't want to shut this tank down after working so hard to put it together. :(

Here's a mini question not related to anything above: In my endler tank, I usually remove the dead little bits of anacharis that fall off the plant. I see a chunk that is soft and rotting, but my ghost shrimp appear to be pulling off chunks and munching on them. So, should I just leave bits of rotting plant matter for them to much on?
 
If you can pop your shrimp and plants into a bucket with an air stone or sponge filter, I'd do that. For the tank with ich- crank the heat back up and start adding salt.
 
If you can pop your shrimp and plants into a bucket with an air stone or sponge filter, I'd do that. For the tank with ich- crank the heat back up and start adding salt.

I don't have an air stone, but can I let my top fin filter hit a lower water level in the bucket for extra surface movement? I have been told that that is as effective as an airstone. I can get a large enough bucket to accommodate the plants-on-driftwood tomorrow. Would the plants-on-driftwood transmit the ich parasites back into the tank when I add them again? Their roots have taken hold of the wood, so I don't want to rip them off. (I have read that the shrimp don't carry the same diseases that the fish have, so moving them would be safe)
 
Argh no! Definitely don't rip them off the wood!

I think ich can only live a few days without a host, so your plants will cope with that. I'm assuming that there is a chance that there is ich on the plant/wood surfaces. I've also heard that shrimp can't carry the parasite.
And a filter is always preferable to a bubbler! :)
 
Argh no! Definitely don't rip them off the wood!

I think ich can only live a few days without a host, so your plants will cope with that. I'm assuming that there is a chance that there is ich on the plant/wood surfaces. I've also heard that shrimp can't carry the parasite.
And a filter is always preferable to a bubbler! :)

Only a few days? I've read that they can go several months! Would it harm the plants if I put them in a salt solution for a half an hour or so? They are hardy stuff like java fern and anubias. Though I have read that my hornwort won't tolerate the salt at all. :(
 
Only a few days? I've read that they can go several months! Would it harm the plants if I put them in a salt solution for a half an hour or so? They are hardy stuff like java fern and anubias. Though I have read that my hornwort won't tolerate the salt at all. :(

I wouldn't use salt. Put a heater in the bucket with the plants in to speed up the process. It definitely shouldn't take more than a week without a host for the ich parasites to die.
 
I wouldn't use salt. Put a heater in the bucket with the plants in to speed up the process. It definitely shouldn't take more than a week without a host for the ich parasites to die.

86 degrees won't hurt the shrimp, will it? that has been about the natural room temperature for several days, actually. I may not even need a heater.
 
Back
Top Bottom