Mcmcoker
Aquarium Advice Activist
If you like angels the annularis, majestic and regal would all be show stoppers in my opinion
Looking for a "center piece" fish
- Thread starter Breakthecycle2
- Start date
The friendliest place on the web for anyone with an interest in aquariums or fish keeping!
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
TheTodd
Aquarium Advice Addict
Those are all beautiful Angels, but I would not put a fish that gets a foot long in a 90g.
Jacobsal91
Aquarium Advice FINatic
How about a butterfly or achillies tang??? Depends on the type of corals you have for the butterfly usually
An Achilles tang would be an awful choice, not only do they get large and need at least a 6 foot tank but they are one of the harder fish to keep. Not to mention they are not cheap. I like kole tangs as a smaller tang.
Daniel Fishy
Aquarium Advice Addict
Agree kole tang, pretty hardly and beautiful
Breakthecycle2
Aquarium Advice FINatic
I picked up one of these:
Fijian Arrowhead Soapfish
Fijian Arrowhead Soapfish
Jacobsal91
Aquarium Advice FINatic
I didnt think they got TOO too big
Hmm
The more you know lol
Kole tangs are also very nice we had one at our shop a while back, sold verrrry fast
Achilles can get 8-10" and have a very poor success rate In captivity. They are also my favorite fish and require more on the range of an 8 foot tank with a lot of current due to the surge zone habitat they come from off of Hawaiian coasts. 6 feet would be a bare minimum. Not a beginner fish at all. The best tang for 4 feet tanks are the kole or tomini tang.
Gregcoyote
Aquarium Advice Addict
+1 agree totally.
huma-huma
Aquarium Advice Addict
+1. there was an Achilles in a 10 ft 800g tank at the family owned fish store I worked at. it covered every last inch of that tank
Breakthecycle2
Aquarium Advice FINatic
Well, down the road I will upgrading again, but I came across a small and very good deal on an Achilles Tang, so I picked him up.
huma-huma
Aquarium Advice Addict
bribo12 said:
+1. I believe achilles are listed as expert only on LA. They have a poor success rate in captivity.
Breakthecycle2
Aquarium Advice FINatic
Im not a rookie at this. Yes, it's not "ideal" to have one in a 4ft tank, however, I am gong over 200 gallons next year and therefore, he will be fine by then. Secondly, did he eat before I bought him? Do you buy a car without driving it? I am a proud owner of many rare and very hard to get fish that have survived and are thriving.
I apologize if I am coming off defensive, but the tang police bother me. I am not throwing in a hippo tang in a 30 gallon tank here.
I apologize if I am coming off defensive, but the tang police bother me. I am not throwing in a hippo tang in a 30 gallon tank here.
carey
Aquarium Advice Addict
Believe it or not, usually the tang police are in it to help the fish. I am a huge advocate for proper fish in the proper tank. An achilles is also a tough fish, which needed to be mentioned. There are hundreds of people reading these threads and I know with you being an experienced aquarist you dont want to send the wrong message. All those people who drop a blue tang in a biocube read or heard from somewhere that it was ok. You understand my point right? lol It's not bash you but to hopefully be helpful. 
I hope your fish does well, alot dont but some do with the proper care. Just provide the care you can and it might be fine. I've battled the odds with several fish and have won a few and lost a few. Just how it is.
I hope your fish does well, alot dont but some do with the proper care. Just provide the care you can and it might be fine. I've battled the odds with several fish and have won a few and lost a few. Just how it is.
If the car was super nice and I had the money, yes I would probably buy it without driving it. A lot of people do the same with fish believe it or not. i don't know your fish background, sorry...I wasn't trying to bash you for getting it. I just don't get why people ask for advice, ignore it and buy a fish anyway. I was also not trying to be tang police at all, I just said it was a poor choice for that tank and wished you good luck with him.
TheTodd
Aquarium Advice Addict
I agree with Carey... I very frequently point out when people are considering putting a fish in a tank that is not appropriate. I do not care if it is a Tang or Angel or whatever. If that has some kind of negative vibe to it, then so be it. To simply not point things out seems irresponsible to me.
You are a brave soul, IMO. I have been doing this for a long time and I would never consider purchasing an "expert only" fish that stores warn should really not go in a home aquarium. Ive done "difficult", but that is a big step up, IMO. If I ever did, I would have the appropriate sized tank, proper filtration and flow, etc. That's just me though.
Best of luck to you and this fish. It's in there and I don't think anyone here is hoping the Tang doesn't make it.
You are a brave soul, IMO. I have been doing this for a long time and I would never consider purchasing an "expert only" fish that stores warn should really not go in a home aquarium. Ive done "difficult", but that is a big step up, IMO. If I ever did, I would have the appropriate sized tank, proper filtration and flow, etc. That's just me though.
Best of luck to you and this fish. It's in there and I don't think anyone here is hoping the Tang doesn't make it.
huma-huma
Aquarium Advice Addict
This is the way that i look at it. You bought this insanely gorgeous fish, that is extremely hard to keep. You are gonna do everything possible to keep him alive, inluding constant water changes, buying higher quality food, upgrading equipment to better suit the task of caring for this fish.. And if you dont upgrade, youll have to rehome him and itll all be for nothing. All your hard work, time and extra money. Im not cpndemning you for purchasing him, and i understand you plan on upgrading, but more often than not our plans get cancelled or pushed back. Would hate to see you go through all that just to possibly rehome him down the road
Daniel Fishy
Aquarium Advice Addict
I would rather see someone who is experience and wants to do his best to take care of the fish.rather than someone who just buys it and doesn't really no what to do. The lfs is not going to release it back were it came from if they can't sell it. Just going to die there. So good luck and I'm happy you found your fish.
Breakthecycle2
Aquarium Advice FINatic
Thanks everyone. Day 5 and no ich yet. He's picking on pellets and grazing on the rock. He also found the MP40 current and swims in it after doing laps. He's quite funny.
Similar threads
