I have been using Aqueon HOB filters for about 4 years. I think they work fine, and I haven't had a bad experience with them being noisy when using the little filter cover/lid part. They work really well with sand substrate, I always use two filter pad cartridges with them as well.
I also have a handful of AC as well, I think they work well, but sometimes they get a little sticky and won't go back on again after a power outage or maintenance.and that can be dangerous if in a power outage or brown out it doesn't come back on without adding water or removal and/or re-plugging in once or a few times.
If you have a heavily stocked tank use the one which would do the most GPH, gallons per hour.