You know, I think I've seen that site before... but never paid attention to the lava rock portion. I've always heard good things about the pot scrubbers, but also the bad (as far as trapping waste, something that those recommending the lava rock said wouldn't happen nearly as bad). I would kind of like to test it out, but that chart just throws it under the bus. As porous as it looks, it definitely doesn't have much surface area. Thanks for the link, definitely some good info to look in to.